About this edition. This is Antoni Milewski’s post, republished with his permission. Only the photographs he chose are used. Those on iNaturalist under a Creative Commons licence are shown; the rest are hosted externally and are given as links. No images have been substituted. Read the original on iNaturalist.

Photographs on iNaturalistAssembled by the author in the comment thread beneath his post on jackals

Both partsPart 1·Part 2

Catoptric effects in the kekebero

The following shows a subtle aspect of the conspicuous colouration in Canis simensis.

As shown in part 1, this species possesses both a caudal flagg and a pedal flagg.

Caudal flaggAlamy 1·Alamy 2

Pedal flaggAlamy

Canis simensis, Bale, Oromia, Ethiopia, by fl66
Frédéric LEVIEZBale, Oromia, Ethiopia · 26 Oct 2007CC BY-NCobs. 124088221
Canis simensis, Bale, Oromia, Ethiopia, by markuslilje
markus liljeBale, Oromia, Ethiopia · 1 Dec 2009CC BY-NC-NDobs. 6629732

For further illustrations, please see the two comments on the author’s post on jackals, and the photographs reproduced from them in part 1 and in the Bio-edge edition of that post.

Further illustrationsComment 1·Comment 2·Jackals, on Bio-edge·Part 1

In both cases, conspicuousness is at least partly owing to whiteness.

WhitenessAlamy

Canis simensis, Bale, Oromia, Ethiopia, by avocat

Second photograph in the observation

avocatBale, Oromia, Ethiopia · 6 Dec 2025CC BYobs. 335773033
Canis simensis, Bale, Oromia, Ethiopia, by alex_willow
Александра ИвушкинаBale, Oromia, Ethiopia · 23 Nov 2025CC BY-NCobs. 336796850

However, the white on the tail is owing only to depigmentation, whereas the white on the forefoot is owing to depigmentation (incomplete) plus ‘sheen’.

Canis simensis, Bale, Oromia, Ethiopia, by abate1
Abate FentawBale, Oromia, Ethiopia · 1 Mar 2026CC BY-NCobs. 343777399
Canis simensis, Bale, Oromia, Ethiopia, by janconl
janconlBale, Oromia, Ethiopia · 12 Dec 2015CC BY-NC-SAobs. 41287105

The ‘sheen’ in question is not visible in the following two photographs, owing to the angle of illumination.

Sheen not visibleGetty·Shutterstock

The ‘sheen’ necessary to ‘light up’ the inner surface of the lower foreleg, making it white, is an example of pilocatoptric effects.

Pilocatoptric effectsCatoptric effects in alcelaphine bovids, part 1

The following shows the pedal flagg in illumination lacking the ‘sheen’ effect. The pelage on the inner surface of the lower foreleg is pale owing to depigmentation, but would seem white only with the additional catoptric effect.

CitedDreamstime

The following is an even clearer illustration of the fact that the inner surface of the lower foreleg is not actually white in the sense of depigmentation.

CitedDreamstime

In the following, the pedal flagg has been activated by locomotion, but lacks the accentuation provided by ‘sheen’. It is conspicuously pale, but not white as required for full effectiveness as a social (intraspecific) signal.

CitedDreamstime

In the following, the pilocatoptric effect is complete, and the pedal flagg appears as white.

CitedDreamstime 1·Dreamstime 2

The following shows the whiteness at both the tail (depigmentation) and the foreleg (depigmentation plus ‘sheen’).

CitedGetty

The following is, overall, the best of the photos available free from iNaturalist:

Canis simensis, Bale, Oromia, Ethiopia, by markuslilje
markus liljeBale, Oromia, Ethiopia · 4 Feb 2013CC BY-NC-NDobs. 93393969

Further photographs cited by the author

Added by Antoni Milewski in comments beneath the original post.

Further photographsiStock 1·iStock 2·iStock 3

Clear illustration of caudal flagg.

VideoiStock

Shift.

Mountain nyalaiStock

Unusual views of caudal flagg.

CitedAlamy 1·Alamy 2·Alamy 3

Credits. Photographs reproduced from iNaturalist are shown under the Creative Commons licence stated in each caption and remain the copyright of the observers named. All other images cited by the author are hosted externally and are linked, not reproduced.

By Antoni V Milewski and Anthony J Mills. Text by Antoni V Milewski, posted on iNaturalist 6 August 2026 and republished here with permission. Read the original.